US federal court holds GHG2 implementation

A US federal court has stopped the implementation of new heavy duty truck and trailer greenhouse gas regulations standards (GHG2), following the Truck Trailer Manufacturer Association’s (TTMA) petitions for review.

The GHG2 implementation was expected to occur January 2018.

The TTMA said that the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) reviewed its petitions for reconsideration of GHG2 for heavy duty trailers in August, agreeing that further rulemaking was needed.

The TTMA petitioned the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia on 22 December 2016, providing explanations for its stance on GHG2.

“EPA lacks authority to regulate trailers under the Clean Air Act (CAA),” the TTMA said.

“The CAA grants authority to the EPA to regulate motor vehicles – specifically, “self-propelled” vehicles. Trailers are neither motorised nor self-propelled. Trailers move a tremendous amount of goods in interstate commerce. If Congress had intended for EPA to regulate trailers, it would have included trailers in the definition of a motor vehicle when it enacted the CAA.

“TTMA has long been a supporter of the EPA SmartWay program, which provides test data and analysis of new trailer equipment such as aerodynamic side skirts and tail devices that, within limited parameters and for certain trailer uses, will promote greater fuel efficiency and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Under this voluntary program, and considering that fuel cost is a major cost component for motor carrier operations, there is already a compelling incentive for the owners and operators of heavy trailers to add this equipment where these benefits can be achieved.

“But most trailers are operated in such a way as to get little or no benefit from these design changes, and these are the trailers that the new GHG2 rules would affect. EPA used unrealistic speed assumptions for trailer use when it calculated the supposed benefits of the new rules. Most trailers do not travel at the high speeds for the lengthy periods that EPA assumes. Trailers used in short haul and local delivery operations travel mostly at lower speeds and would gain no benefit from EPA’s mandated equipment. In fact, the added weight of the EPA mandated equipment will decrease fuel efficiency in these operations.

“The EPA regulations would actually result in more miles driven and, of greater concern, would increase highway accidents. Motor carriers must operate within defined limits for the combined weight of the tractor, trailer and cargo. The added weight of EPA’s mandated GHG2 equipment would increase the trailer weight, and in many instances this would require that some cargo be removed from the trailer and transported on a different trailer.

“As a result, more heavy duty trucks would be required to operate in order to move the nation’s cargo, and on average the trucks would be heavier. Adding more and heavier trucks to the nation’s highways would produce more accidents involving these trucks, which is contrary to NHTSA’s defined mission.

The TTMA elaborated on its concerns regarding the now defunct GHG2 January 2018 implementation date.

“Most heavy duty trailers are custom-ordered, and the required lead time for scheduling production means that trailer manufacturers are having to quote orders for 2018 delivery that will force customers to purchase equipment they do not want and that will not produce any fuel efficiencies in the customers’ operations,” according to TTMA. “Moreover, much of this equipment is still not certified by EPA, so trailer manufacturers are not certain if they can incorporate the equipment into future orders and still comply with the regulations.”

Leave a Reply